1. Home
  2. Cruise Lines
  3. P&O Cruises
  4. Arcadia Review
  5. Arcadia Cruise Reviews
Cruise Ratings
See Reviews For
8 Helpful Votes
Sail Date: January 2017
What a wonderful adventure we have been on! We originally chose this cruise for the itinerary and it didn't disappoint, however we ended up enjoying our sea days so much more than we expected. There is so much to do on board the ... Read More
What a wonderful adventure we have been on! We originally chose this cruise for the itinerary and it didn't disappoint, however we ended up enjoying our sea days so much more than we expected. There is so much to do on board the ship, but the highlight of our particular cruise were the ballroom dance lessons taught by the very talented, kind and funny teachers Jeffrey and Brenda. They were so good that by evening number two we were up and having a go in the Globe Theatre. We met some lovely people and have some very happy memories of our evenings there. The staff were friendly and helpful, there was so much choice when it came to eating and the menu, when the sea was rough the captain slowed the bost/sped it up so we travelled through the worst of it overnight. The deck parties when leaving port were grat fun. We had to leave the boat in San Francisco, but would have happily stayed on. What a fabulous way to see the world! I can't recommend it enough, I know some people have a few niggles with things, but don't let it put you off. Most people are happy and friendly and pleased to be on board and are more than willing to share their top tips for making the most of the holiday. We would love to go back someday and do another leg of the World cruise with P and O. Read Less
8 Helpful Votes
Sail Date: January 2017
I have to admit that I was concerned about choosing P&O Arcadia for our cruise from San Francisco - Sydney when I saw all the poor reviews compared to the reviews on our usual cruise line, Royal Caribbean. However, the timing and ... Read More
I have to admit that I was concerned about choosing P&O Arcadia for our cruise from San Francisco - Sydney when I saw all the poor reviews compared to the reviews on our usual cruise line, Royal Caribbean. However, the timing and itinerary was right for us, so we decided to risk it and I'm so glad we did! From the beginning, we were treated wonderfully by the staff, both our cabin attendant, our waiters and every service member we came across! They were all gracious and kind. My husband has a special diet and the attention and care he received in the dining room was absolutely amazing - special advance ordering of dinner menu's, along with great advice and knowledge on the part of the head waiter in charge of that. Thank you Abel! On one evening, when we were dining in the specialty restaurant, our head waiter even popped up there to take my husband's order for the following evening! We chose early seating dinner (1830, or 6:30pm for us Americans), and met two wonderful couples to fill out our international table of 6 - from New Zealand, Britian and America. When our New Zealand couple disembarked, we had a wonderful gentlemen couple from the UK that we wished we'd had more time to come to know. They were fabulous people and great conversationalists! Although I truly enjoyed the itinerary and the ports, the sea days were also a real treat on this cruise. The ship was roomy and never felt over-full. We almost always had our choice of lovely places to sit. Drink prices in the bars were very reasonable and no gratuity added to each purchase, as they are on our usual American cruises. I enjoyed watercolor classes each morning and found many friendly passengers, willing to share their tables, introduce themselves and chat. The highlight of this cruise for us was the ballroom dancing classes! Jeffrey and Brenda were amazingly patient, kind and funny teachers who led us through 14 new dances and hosted evening dances in the Globe theater where we could practice our new skills. Out of the 14 dances we had so much fun learning, we only really retained 3 of them for the long-term. Many were "sequence dances" which were so much fun to learn and participate in on our cruise, but aren't popular in the U.S., so we won't worry too much that we can't remember them. But we'll always fondly remember our super fun, overcrowded dance classes and evening dances with all the other wonderful couples - laughing along with Jeffrey and Brenda as we stumbled into each other on the floor. The ship even had a "Tea Dance" with lovely special pastries and teas exclusively for the dance class participants. I'll always remember that lovely touch. I felt that P&O really went the extra mile to include every passenger in "the party". The dance classes and watercolor classes were free with the cruise, and really made the cruise for us, giving us a venue for activities where we could meet others and enjoy. The entertainment on the ship was top notch. The ships headliners were fabulous and had quite a few different shows. Every one of them was wonderful. I was wowed with the level of talent and always looked forward to seeing what was next. As Americans, our only disappointment was the buffet, which we found almost always underwhelming. I'm afraid much of that may have been cultural, since we normally eat large salads at lunch time and there didn't seem to be much of a salad selection. Often there would be lettuce, corn, beets, sometimes hard boiled eggs and one or two watered down salad dressings - thousand island mostly. I normally made do with a small salad and the soup of the day which was usually pretty good. Food being food, we managed. And we enjoyed the occasional afternoon tea with all the yummy scones and pastries! I had to wonder on this cruise if I was on the same ship that I read all the poor reviews on before we embarked? We loved every minute of our 24 days on Arcadia! Read Less
Sail Date: January 2015
We have just returned from a cruise on the Arcadia - San Francisco to Sydney - and to say we were disappointed is an understatement. Having sailed on the last world voyage of the Oriana in 2012 from Brisbane to San Francisco, we were ... Read More
We have just returned from a cruise on the Arcadia - San Francisco to Sydney - and to say we were disappointed is an understatement. Having sailed on the last world voyage of the Oriana in 2012 from Brisbane to San Francisco, we were expecting a similar fabulous experience. The Arcadia had little to offer in the way of entertainment, shops and service. It is widely known that once on board you are captive and the prices are steep, but the Arcadia did absolutely nothing to disguise or sweeten the pill. For instance: I purchased a Citizen Eco Watch in the morning and was told to come back at 3.00pm because I needed to have two links removed from the strap. I returned at 3.30pm and was told the strap had not yet been altered and to come back at 5.30pm. The job was done in two minutes while I waited. Often Bar Stewards on the pool decks spent a great deal of time chatting and were nowhere to be seen. I ordered a Tom Collins, but with lemonade and not Soda Water. This was just too hard because their computerised billing system stipulated Soda Water and it would throw their stocktaking out. It is a bit rich to charge £6 for a double Southern Comfort (without a mixer) when a litre bottle in the Duty Free Shop costs £19, bearing in mind the ship not only buys everything duty free, they get a quantity discount from the suppliers as well. In Maui the ship charged £51 for the whale watching tour. On shore, the most expensive tour on offer that we saw was US$16. The Laundrettes (on three decks with three washers and dryers each) were totally inadequate and situated in very tiny cubicles so that passengers using these facilities were squashed in like sardines. The washers took 45 minutes to complete the cycle - a ridiculous amount of time for clothes that merely needed to be freshened up. I have come to the conclusion that the enjoyment of a cruise also depends largely on the time of year and where one boards the ship as to the make up of the passengers, which of course the shipping line has no control over. For instance, sailing from Galveston on Thanksgiving on a family friendly ship can be a nightmare if the ship does not have an adult only area!   Read Less
1 Helpful Vote
Sail Date: January 2015
After two nights in San Francisco we boarded Arcadia for our voyage through the Pacific to Sydney. First impression was that the staff looked worn out. I do understand that change-over days are hectic & tiring for them all. All went ... Read More
After two nights in San Francisco we boarded Arcadia for our voyage through the Pacific to Sydney. First impression was that the staff looked worn out. I do understand that change-over days are hectic & tiring for them all. All went reasonably well for the first four days & the food was quite acceptable but then my wife developed what we were to find out was called "Arcadia Cough", I got it a couple of days later. There were hundreds of passengers affected & the ship's shop had run out of stock of cough syrup before reaching San Francisco! Fortunately we were able to buy some from the medical section. This cough really did spoil our holiday in many ways. My wife was reluctant to go to theatre shows knowing she would most likely have a coughing fit. We chose not to join a dining table with other guests for the same reason, & we normally like to have interaction with others. The menus soon became repetitive & the entertainment just mediocre. Our grade EA deluxe balcony cabin, number A106 on deck eight, was reasonably well appointed but no bathrobes supplied. Last year on Aurora in the same cabin grade they were supplied. Also it was not possible to switch off the air conditioning, just turn it up or down; we're sure Arcadia Cough must be something to do with the air-con systems on this ship. The ports of call were a little disappointing too, Honolulu was our first stop...a horrible city! But Lahaina on Maui, our second stop, was lovely. Then five sea days before reaching Pago Pago in American Samoa, another disappointment as was the next stop in Apia, Samoa. Then on to Suva, Fiji, which was okay. Finally four more sea days to our final destination of Sydney. We only booked one shore excursion with P & O, a whale watching & lunch trip in Honolulu. Distinctly average food & an overpriced trip. We do tend to arrange our own excursions on arrival in ports, far more economical. Read Less
Sail Date: January 2015
After two nights in San Francisco we boarded Arcadia for our voyage through the Pacific to Sydney. First impression was that the staff looked worn out. I do understand that change-over days are hectic & tiring for them all. All went ... Read More
After two nights in San Francisco we boarded Arcadia for our voyage through the Pacific to Sydney. First impression was that the staff looked worn out. I do understand that change-over days are hectic & tiring for them all. All went reasonably well for the first four days & the food was quite acceptable but then my wife developed what we were to find out was called "Arcadia Cough", I got it a couple of days later. There were hundreds of passengers affected & the ship's shop had run out of stock of cough syrup before reaching San Francisco! Fortunately we were able to buy some from the medical section. This cough really did spoil our holiday in many ways. My wife was reluctant to go to theatre shows knowing she would most likely have a coughing fit. We chose not to join a dining table with other guests for the same reason, & we normally like to have interaction with others. The menus soon became repetitive & the entertainment just mediocre. Our grade EA deluxe balcony cabin, number A106 on deck eight, was reasonably well appointed but no bathrobes supplied. Last year on Aurora in the same cabin grade they were supplied. Also it was not possible to switch off the air conditioning, just turn it up or down; we're sure Arcadia Cough must be something to do with the air-con systems on this ship. The ports of call were a little disappointing too, Honolulu was our first stop...a horrible city! But Lahaina on Maui, our second stop, was lovely. Then five sea days before reaching Pago Pago in American Samoa, another disappointment as was the next stop in Apia, Samoa. Then on to Suva, Fiji, which was okay. Finally four more sea days to our final destination of Sydney. We only booked one shore excursion with P & O, a whale watching & lunch trip in Honolulu. Distinctly average food & an overpriced trip. We do tend to arrange our own excursions on arrival in ports, far more economical. Read Less
Arcadia Ratings
Category Editor Member
Cabins 4.0 4.0
Dining 3.0 3.7
Entertainment 4.0 3.5
Public Rooms 4.0 3.9
Fitness Recreation 4.0 3.6
Family 1.0 3.6
Shore Excursion 4.0 3.4
Enrichment 3.0 3.2
Service 4.0 4.1
Value For Money 4.0 3.4
Rates 4.0 3.7

Find a Cruise

Easily compare prices from multiple sites with one click
Compare and book excursions for your next cruise