We flew out of Perth on Boxing Day, West Australia, for this cruise, we thought it would be the best cruise experience with exotic ports of calls and were so eager to experience these. Have cruised for many many years, but this was the worst experience on the high seas we have had. OK so the steering gear didn't want to work but at least we were in Southampton! Glad it wasn't in the middle of the Pacific or Atlantic. Having a problem with certain foods I wrote to P & O months in advance naming items I could not have. We dined in the main dining room so my diet could be accommodated I was given food that I threw up! I felt very vunerable as I wondered what other meals I was going to get a reaction to. Phoned Reception to let them know and was then contacted by a nurse in the Medical Centre by phone. I was told to keep in my Cabin and not go out on the paid Tour of Madeira we had just arrived at! Why we asked? Having told them it was a reaction to food I should not have been given. The reply came back You may have the Norovirus! Great, I asked if I get a reaction to food again and let the Reception know [so the bathroom can be cleaned] I will be treated as some dirty passenger that doesn't wash their hands after going to the loo will I? Yes, came the reply back, you may have the Norovirus! Well what a difference in shipping lines my husband and I thought. Here I was been given food I should not have and I get treated like this. The year before on the Maasdam [Holland America] same thing happened but the doctor at least checked me over and was happy for me to mix with the passengers as she said you haven't the virus. Their medical centre gave me medication to help my digestive system. Not P & O Arcadia, I was not even seen by a member of the medical team! Then we get to Aruba and my husband was not well, he lost his voice and had a temperature. Turns out a passenger had been let on board the ship with a nasty virus, my guess was at least 50% of the passengers caught this virus. The virus made heavy mucous in the Trachea, so the patient coughs very hard to try to get the mucas up. Husband was put on anti biotics, a week later I had the same infection and same treatment. The virus affected my throat and my well being for the rest of the cruise till we got to Sydney. Why do they let sick people on board and allow them to mix in public areas while infectious? They should be kept in confinement like I was when I didn't have the Norovirus. I have had three lots of antibiotics and my voice is still affected. Enjoyed the Quiz Night in the Crows Nest though, but it was a bit late at 10.30pm! The beds were very comfortable but the bed linen always smelt of sweat even when they were changed with new bedding! The air conditioning was not consistant in temperature, we ended up having a new control. But I rather suspect the air conditioning was not affective due to the people next to us leaving their doors open as they smoked on their balcony and the wind blew their smoke into our balcony. I agree with another comment here that the Hotel Manager of the Ship doesn't manage smokers! One evening at dinner one of the guys mentioned he had approached a smoker on the Promenade deck smoking, so the smoker throws his cigarette over board which as a regular cruiser we know that could cause a fire! We were all aghast. The rear lifts on our deck B were always smelling of smoke, the carpets in those lifts were always dirty, in fact we had never seen such dirty carpet in the lifts as we had the Arcadia. We saw cleaners in the evenings when we went down to dinner cleaning the buttons of the Lift, but that is the only time, unlike Holland America where cleaners are always busy cleaning everything. Hawaiian Tour was pleasant and we were lucky to have a 24 seater bus! More personal. However, the driver finished 10 minutes earlier than planned and was told to make the time up instead of returning to the ship. When we did return to the ship we and approx 300 others had to stand in line for scanning by the US authorities. Most of us were senior Citizens, and some were disabled. No thought had been addressed to accommodate the waiting in line for 40 odd minutes to be scanned. When we get on board the main Dining Room was closed, so my disabled husband had to go to find food up on deck 9 without me. With crutches it was not easy. I was told to remain in my cabin and my 'special meal' would be brought to me, so we could not eat together! Sadly we had to complain to the Cabin Steward who was very accommodating and pleasant, nothing was too much trouble for him, that our shower recess grouting when we boarded had black mould. He explained he was not allowed to use bleach and would have to get someone in to clean the dirty grout. Later we were asked by the Deck Manager if he could get the tiles regrouted! Not wanting to experience the smell of chemicals with the glue we declined. Ten days out of Sydney we finally were able to clean out teeth in cold water, up till then we had to use hot water, we had complained earlier, but was told that the plumber did not have the relevant pipes to make the cold water come to the tap in the vanity basins. We do not think this was $44,000 + worth of cruise although it was 7 weeks, the mini suite was fine, the Head Waiter Manuel was fantastic, he would go that extra mile where others would not! Would we go on P & O Europe again? NEVER if that is the best they can come up with!

Poor value for the money!

Arcadia Cruise Review by Kalleroo

2 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: December 2018
  • Destination: Europe
  • Cabin Type: Mini Suite with Balcony and Bath/Shower
We flew out of Perth on Boxing Day, West Australia, for this cruise, we thought it would be the best cruise experience with exotic ports of calls and were so eager to experience these. Have cruised for many many years, but this was the worst experience on the high seas we have had. OK so the steering gear didn't want to work but at least we were in Southampton! Glad it wasn't in the middle of the Pacific or Atlantic. Having a problem with certain foods I wrote to P & O months in advance naming items I could not have. We dined in the main dining room so my diet could be accommodated I was given food that I threw up! I felt very vunerable as I wondered what other meals I was going to get a reaction to. Phoned Reception to let them know and was then contacted by a nurse in the Medical Centre by phone. I was told to keep in my Cabin and not go out on the paid Tour of Madeira we had just arrived at! Why we asked? Having told them it was a reaction to food I should not have been given. The reply came back You may have the Norovirus! Great, I asked if I get a reaction to food again and let the Reception know [so the bathroom can be cleaned] I will be treated as some dirty passenger that doesn't wash their hands after going to the loo will I? Yes, came the reply back, you may have the Norovirus! Well what a difference in shipping lines my husband and I thought. Here I was been given food I should not have and I get treated like this. The year before on the Maasdam [Holland America] same thing happened but the doctor at least checked me over and was happy for me to mix with the passengers as she said you haven't the virus. Their medical centre gave me medication to help my digestive system. Not P & O Arcadia, I was not even seen by a member of the medical team!

Then we get to Aruba and my husband was not well, he lost his voice and had a temperature. Turns out a passenger had been let on board the ship with a nasty virus, my guess was at least 50% of the passengers caught this virus. The virus made heavy mucous in the Trachea, so the patient coughs very hard to try to get the mucas up. Husband was put on anti biotics, a week later I had the same infection and same treatment. The virus affected my throat and my well being for the rest of the cruise till we got to Sydney. Why do they let sick people on board and allow them to mix in public areas while infectious? They should be kept in confinement like I was when I didn't have the Norovirus. I have had three lots of antibiotics and my voice is still affected.

Enjoyed the Quiz Night in the Crows Nest though, but it was a bit late at 10.30pm!

The beds were very comfortable but the bed linen always smelt of sweat even when they were changed with new bedding! The air conditioning was not consistant in temperature, we ended up having a new control. But I rather suspect the air conditioning was not affective due to the people next to us leaving their doors open as they smoked on their balcony and the wind blew their smoke into our balcony. I agree with another comment here that the Hotel Manager of the Ship doesn't manage smokers! One evening at dinner one of the guys mentioned he had approached a smoker on the Promenade deck smoking, so the smoker throws his cigarette over board which as a regular cruiser we know that could cause a fire! We were all aghast.

The rear lifts on our deck B were always smelling of smoke, the carpets in those lifts were always dirty, in fact we had never seen such dirty carpet in the lifts as we had the Arcadia. We saw cleaners in the evenings when we went down to dinner cleaning the buttons of the Lift, but that is the only time, unlike Holland America where cleaners are always busy cleaning everything.

Hawaiian Tour was pleasant and we were lucky to have a 24 seater bus! More personal. However, the driver finished 10 minutes earlier than planned and was told to make the time up instead of returning to the ship. When we did return to the ship we and approx 300 others had to stand in line for scanning by the US authorities. Most of us were senior Citizens, and some were disabled. No thought had been addressed to accommodate the waiting in line for 40 odd minutes to be scanned. When we get on board the main Dining Room was closed, so my disabled husband had to go to find food up on deck 9 without me. With crutches it was not easy. I was told to remain in my cabin and my 'special meal' would be brought to me, so we could not eat together!

Sadly we had to complain to the Cabin Steward who was very accommodating and pleasant, nothing was too much trouble for him, that our shower recess grouting when we boarded had black mould. He explained he was not allowed to use bleach and would have to get someone in to clean the dirty grout. Later we were asked by the Deck Manager if he could get the tiles regrouted! Not wanting to experience the smell of chemicals with the glue we declined. Ten days out of Sydney we finally were able to clean out teeth in cold water, up till then we had to use hot water, we had complained earlier, but was told that the plumber did not have the relevant pipes to make the cold water come to the tap in the vanity basins.

We do not think this was $44,000 + worth of cruise although it was 7 weeks, the mini suite was fine, the Head Waiter Manuel was fantastic, he would go that extra mile where others would not! Would we go on P & O Europe again? NEVER if that is the best they can come up with!
Kalleroo’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Fitness & Recreation
Shore Excursions
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Arcadia price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Cabin Review

Mini Suite with Balcony and Bath/Shower
Cabin BD B95
The bed was very comfortable, but the bedding did not smell fresh. More hanging space would have been useful. TV needs to be placed on the wall in front of the bed, so the passengers do not have to twist their necks to watch tv. Loved the use of the iron and ironing board, that was the one thing that was very appreciative also the coffee machine and kettle in the mini suite. Would have preferred no mould in the shower and also cold water available in the vanity taps.
  Arcadia Deck Plans