1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Independence of the Seas
Not a ship for voyages with multiple sea days in indifferent weather....just not enough space without using the outside decks. But a minor difficulty on this trip and much to enjoy. This was first full cruise out of dry dock for Independence of the Seas We are a senior couple with a young outlook and have cruised on Brilliance of the Seas, Royal Princess and P&O's Ventura and Azura. This was a brilliant holiday for us but admit we were lucky with the weather and the excursions we planned for ourselves. Embarkation (and disembarkation) were highly efficient. We drove from Leeds to Salisbury the day before and on to Southampton the morning of departure. We had been allocated a boarding time but I made a minor enquiry by email in advance and the response implied we could turn up when we liked. We left our car with a meet and greet company in the short term car park and were on board within half an hour, two hours early! Good news for the Brits. There are kettles in the cabins. The drinks price list INCLUDES gratuities. Some waiters in the main dining room actually put the tea bag in the pot BEFORE the hot water (and do not just bring a tea bag on the side). But not all waiters have learned this yet so you will need to train them!! In fact there were very few North Americans on board (maybe 300) and even fewer from other countries. Also Independence entertainment staff are heavily British. We did not have a drinks package so needed to watch bar prices. Best value for drinks I found was gin & tonic with a very generous shot of gin at $8.50. A bottle of beer from $7.75, cheapest glass of wine $8. No regular “happy hours” but a $9 “drink of the day”, available everywhere, ranged from a Pimms to a Singapore Sling Food in Windjammer buffet restaurant was very good. Free soft drink or iced tea available, variety of food astonishing, quality high in the main. Problem was at busy times you had to search for a table and hang onto it so we rarely ate together at breakfast or lunch. Dinner was quieter. Main dining room was really good for breakfast with buffet service as varied as Windjammer (we did not use waiter service section) but ended at 9:30 compared to 11am for Windjammer. Lunch here was part buffet, part waiter service but if we ate lunch on board we often took a sandwich from Royal Promenade cafe to our balcony. Evening meals in the main dining rooms were mostly very good with an occasional poor dish. We had freedom dining and found waiters were not all experienced. So there were slow times, less knowledge and I felt no encouragement to indulge at some tables. People mostly dressed up on formal nights but I did not feel that I was out of place for not wearing the full dinner suit, bow tie and starched shirt. As seems to be the trend for larger ships in the Royal Theatre they offer a full West End style show, Grease, on Independence. This was very well done with a cast of over 20 and all the famous songs. As they cannot fit in two performances a night they have to do two nights plus a matinee so everyone can see it. Consequently the ships company only did one additional show on our eight night cruise. Four other major acts were 75% successful only the comedy magician being weak. The number two venue for entertainment is the ice rink which has a spectacular show with ten professional skaters and a talented solo violinist. A regular on board said they had seen it eight times. I do not know if that was a tribute to quality or a hint they need to change the act! Available for open skating during the day at times they can cover over the ice and use it as a dance floor for a nightclub or it can be an 800 seat amphitheatre. For popular shows we learned to be 30 minutes early to get a good seat, otherwise 15 mins is OK The Star show lounge is smaller than on other ships but when not in use is available as extra seating on sea days. The Royal Promenade is the focal point of the ship and intended to be a high street with different shops and bars to give atmosphere. This is successful and offers great ambience in the evenings and when the weather is too bad to use the pool deck. The trouble is whenever it is the right time to be here you can never find a seat. Other areas are the same- when there is a quiz in the Schooner Bar, when the band are playing in Boleros- there are no seats. Those who knew the old Indy said the nightclub on decks 3 & 4 was a useful daytime quiet area as well as an evening venue. Now it is Laser Quest and Izumi. And what was the most sophisticated bar on the ship, Olive and Twist, now has karaoke every night. The refit additions, Water Slides, VR trampoline, Escape Room, Laser Quest are mainly for the teens and young adults. Pool deck is in three areas, adults only at front, then everyone with stage for band and giant screen, followed by kids splash area. All well designed with hot tubs in various places usable even on cold days. There looks to be enough sun beds for every single person on ship on various decks but obviously those next to a pool will be fought over. We are not spa users or fitness fanatics so no comments in that area. No classic "enrichment" of any kind. Only selling seminars or quizes. I think some bridge players got the use of the dining room but I saw nothing else on the daily planner other than napkin folding! But this was a port heavy cruise with only two sea days so not important.

Smart refit for large ship fighting for UK's family cruisers

Independence of the Seas Cruise Review by Espire

1 person found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: May 2018
  • Destination: Baltic Sea
  • Cabin Type: Spacious Ocean View Balcony
Not a ship for voyages with multiple sea days in indifferent weather....just not enough space without using the outside decks. But a minor difficulty on this trip and much to enjoy. This was first full cruise out of dry dock for Independence of the Seas

We are a senior couple with a young outlook and have cruised on Brilliance of the Seas, Royal Princess and P&O's Ventura and Azura. This was a brilliant holiday for us but admit we were lucky with the weather and the excursions we planned for ourselves.

Embarkation (and disembarkation) were highly efficient. We drove from Leeds to Salisbury the day before and on to Southampton the morning of departure. We had been allocated a boarding time but I made a minor enquiry by email in advance and the response implied we could turn up when we liked. We left our car with a meet and greet company in the short term car park and were on board within half an hour, two hours early!

Good news for the Brits. There are kettles in the cabins. The drinks price list INCLUDES gratuities. Some waiters in the main dining room actually put the tea bag in the pot BEFORE the hot water (and do not just bring a tea bag on the side). But not all waiters have learned this yet so you will need to train them!! In fact there were very few North Americans on board (maybe 300) and even fewer from other countries. Also Independence entertainment staff are heavily British.

We did not have a drinks package so needed to watch bar prices. Best value for drinks I found was gin & tonic with a very generous shot of gin at $8.50. A bottle of beer from $7.75, cheapest glass of wine $8. No regular “happy hours” but a $9 “drink of the day”, available everywhere, ranged from a Pimms to a Singapore Sling

Food in Windjammer buffet restaurant was very good. Free soft drink or iced tea available, variety of food astonishing, quality high in the main. Problem was at busy times you had to search for a table and hang onto it so we rarely ate together at breakfast or lunch. Dinner was quieter.

Main dining room was really good for breakfast with buffet service as varied as Windjammer (we did not use waiter service section) but ended at 9:30 compared to 11am for Windjammer. Lunch here was part buffet, part waiter service but if we ate lunch on board we often took a sandwich from Royal Promenade cafe to our balcony.

Evening meals in the main dining rooms were mostly very good with an occasional poor dish. We had freedom dining and found waiters were not all experienced. So there were slow times, less knowledge and I felt no encouragement to indulge at some tables. People mostly dressed up on formal nights but I did not feel that I was out of place for not wearing the full dinner suit, bow tie and starched shirt.

As seems to be the trend for larger ships in the Royal Theatre they offer a full West End style show, Grease, on Independence. This was very well done with a cast of over 20 and all the famous songs. As they cannot fit in two performances a night they have to do two nights plus a matinee so everyone can see it. Consequently the ships company only did one additional show on our eight night cruise. Four other major acts were 75% successful only the comedy magician being weak.

The number two venue for entertainment is the ice rink which has a spectacular show with ten professional skaters and a talented solo violinist. A regular on board said they had seen it eight times. I do not know if that was a tribute to quality or a hint they need to change the act! Available for open skating during the day at times they can cover over the ice and use it as a dance floor for a nightclub or it can be an 800 seat amphitheatre.

For popular shows we learned to be 30 minutes early to get a good seat, otherwise 15 mins is OK

The Star show lounge is smaller than on other ships but when not in use is available as extra seating on sea days.

The Royal Promenade is the focal point of the ship and intended to be a high street with different shops and bars to give atmosphere. This is successful and offers great ambience in the evenings and when the weather is too bad to use the pool deck. The trouble is whenever it is the right time to be here you can never find a seat. Other areas are the same- when there is a quiz in the Schooner Bar, when the band are playing in Boleros- there are no seats.

Those who knew the old Indy said the nightclub on decks 3 & 4 was a useful daytime quiet area as well as an evening venue. Now it is Laser Quest and Izumi. And what was the most sophisticated bar on the ship, Olive and Twist, now has karaoke every night. The refit additions, Water Slides, VR trampoline, Escape Room, Laser Quest are mainly for the teens and young adults.

Pool deck is in three areas, adults only at front, then everyone with stage for band and giant screen, followed by kids splash area. All well designed with hot tubs in various places usable even on cold days. There looks to be enough sun beds for every single person on ship on various decks but obviously those next to a pool will be fought over.

We are not spa users or fitness fanatics so no comments in that area. No classic "enrichment" of any kind. Only selling seminars or quizes. I think some bridge players got the use of the dining room but I saw nothing else on the daily planner other than napkin folding! But this was a port heavy cruise with only two sea days so not important.
Espire’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Royal Caribbean Independence of the Seas price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Cabin Review

Spacious Ocean View Balcony
Cabin 2B 6394
Booked guarantee balcony and got this upgrade. Worry that it might be above kitchens was baseless. No noise from above or below whatsoever. Very little vibration only when travelling fast. Large balcony with recliners and table. Extra long sofa in lounge area. Bathroom typical cruise ship but with doors (not curtain) on shower.
Deck 10 Inside Cabins, Outside Cabins, Balcony Cabins, Suite Cabins

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

  • Alesund
    We were going to take the hop on hop off bus but were glad we changed our mind. We heard from others that they were stranded at distant stops because the bus was full and no one was willing to get off. One couple were stuck an hour and a half. We did see some empty seats late in the day but they obviously sold too many tickets.

    We spent the morning in the Art nouveau museum and adjoining art gallery. The town had burnt down in about 1910 and had been rebuilt in Art Nouveau style which is explained in the museum. We walked the streets looking at the buildings and passed the cathedral which was closed. We found a trendy coffee bar overlooking the harbour and found tea or coffee are affordable compared to alcohol!!
    View All 203 Alesund Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Alesund Cruise Port Review
  • Mount Dalsnibba
    Coach drive up mountain on private toll road to very summit with walkway projecting over cliff. Small cafe and shop with toilets. Brilliant summer day but still snow fields to walk on. Spectacular views en route with interesting guide explaining many aspects of local life. On way down asked to be dropped off at fjord centre museum and walked back to port alongside waterfalls and rapids (30 min)
    Fjord centre museum has a cafe and is well worth a look if you are enjoying the landscape
    View All 67 Mount Dalsnibba Reviews
  • Molde
    We arrived at 2:30pm so this was only a half day stop. Main attraction is Romsdaal Outdoor Museum showing life in Norway over past few centuries. Normally this closes at 4pm but because they had a ship in port the stayed open until 7pm. Various old houses collected together with guides in several of them to explain, in good English, plus a baker making flatbreads to serve with fresh churned butter. It was nice to get the comment how pleasant the English were compared to the Germans that had visited that morning. There is also an indoor museum exceptionally well presented if smallish and very good for children. If you go with young ones get them to search for the secret dressing up area!
    View All 38 Molde Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Molde Cruise Port Review